This is a short extract from a novel in progress. The manuscript is still in development, and this opening may change before publication.
Cape Town. Years later.
“When did you first realise Neil Pretorius had lied to you?”
The red light on the recorder remained steady. Across the table, Advocate Lategan rested one hand on a file I had not seen in years. If the panel accepted Neil’s version of how that file reached me, I alone would bear responsibility for everything that followed.
I left the glass of water untouched.
“That isn’t the question I answered.”
“Then help us understand what you did say.”
Behind him, three people lowered their eyes to their notes. The chairperson watched me over the rim of her glasses. A second recorder sat beside the first, its display counting seconds in green. Neil’s chair remained empty, although his statement lay open on the table.
Lategan opened the file.
I recognised the first photograph before he turned it towards me: a white Mercedes Sprinter, its front end folded beneath a strip of orange yard light.
“The Mozambique claim,” he said.
For a moment I heard the salvage yard again: the Cape Doctor hammering corrugated iron and loose metal striking metal beneath the yard lights. That night had taught me how evidence exposed a lie. Years later, the same evidence was being used to decide whose lie it had been.
“You remember it?”
“Yes.”
“This was your first investigation.”
“It wasn’t an investigation when it reached me.”
“What was it?”
“A claim that did not sit right.”
Lategan glanced at the chairperson as if I had supplied the answer he wanted.
“Those were Mr Pretorius’s words?”
“Close enough.”
“Close enough is an unusual standard for a man whose career depends on the difference between an observation and a conclusion.”
The chairperson’s pen stopped. Lategan had done his homework. He knew which habits to turn against me.
“He said, ‘Just see if it sits right.’”
“And you trusted him?”
I looked at the empty chair.
“At the time, I had no reason not to.”
Lategan removed a single page from the file. He did not pass it to me.
“Mr Pretorius says you volunteered.”
“For what?”
“To take the file beyond an ordinary claims assessment.”
“That isn’t how it happened.”
“You’re certain?”
“I remember the file landing beside my keyboard, Neil standing because he said he did not have time to sit, and the corner of the police slip protruding beneath the client’s statement. I did not ask for the file.”
“But you wanted it.”
That was harder to deny. Wanting the file had felt harmless then—proof that Neil trusted my judgement. In this room, the same desire sounded like motive.